Choosing the right suitcase can make the difference between a comfortable trip and an experience full of setbacks. Whether you’re navigating international airports, hilly streets, or public transportation stations, the type of suitcase you choose will be your best ally or your worst enemy.

I vividly remember my trip from Miami to the West Coast of the United States. I visited several cities like Los Angeles and San Francisco, each with its own style, climate, and transportation challenges. I had to think not only about protecting my belongings but also about navigating uneven streets and sidewalks. This trip taught me the importance of choosing between hard-shell, semi-rigid, or soft luggage, as well as the convenience of having the right wheels for different terrains.

In this guide, I’ll show you the different types of suitcases, their features, and help you choose the one that best suits your travel style. Let’s get started!

What Types of Suitcases Are There?

When it comes to choosing a suitcase, the first thing you need to know is that not all of them are the same. Suitcases are mainly classified by the structure of their materials, and each type has its own advantages and disadvantages depending on the kind of trip you’re planning. Here are the three main types:

1. Hard-Shell Suitcases 

Hard-shell suitcases are known for their ability to provide superior protection. They are made from durable materials like polycarbonate or ABS, making them ideal for travelers carrying fragile items such as cameras, laptops, or delicate souvenirs.

Advantages:

• Greater protection against impacts and crushing.
• Water and moisture resistance.

Disadvantages:

• They can be heavier than other types of suitcases.
• They usually don’t have external pockets, limiting quick access to documents or accessories.

Before my trip to California, I seriously considered buying a hard-shell suitcase to protect my camera and other electronic devices. However, after analyzing the terrain I would be walking on (uneven sidewalks and streets), I opted for a lighter and more flexible option.

2. Semi-Rigid Suitcases
   Semi-rigid suitcases offer the best of both worlds. They have a firm external structure but are not completely rigid, allowing for some flexibility. Additionally, they often come with external pockets, which are very practical for quickly accessing documents, chargers, or a light jacket.

Advantages:

• Accessible external pockets.
• A combination of lightness and protection.
• They can expand slightly, providing extra space.

Disadvantages:

• They don’t offer as much protection as hard-shell suitcases in case of crushing.

In the end, I decided on a semi-rigid suitcase. It was the best choice for easily moving through airports and transportation stations in cities like Los Angeles and San Francisco. Being able to store my charger in the external pockets and access it quickly was a huge relief.

3. Soft-Sided Suitcases
   Soft-sided suitcases are the lightest and often the most affordable option. They are made from flexible materials like polyester or nylon, allowing them to expand and provide additional packing space.

Advantages:

• Extremely lightweight, making them easy to carry.
• They often expand, offering extra space when you need it most.

Disadvantages:

• Less protection against impacts or pressure.
• They are more likely to tear or get damaged if heavy objects are placed on top of them.

While soft-sided suitcases are ideal for travelers who need extra space, in my case, I knew I would be carrying fragile items and navigating crowded airports. For that reason, I opted for a semi-rigid suitcase that offered a balance between protection and flexibility.

How Many Types of Luggage Are There?

In addition to the types of suitcases, it’s important to understand the different types of luggage. This classification is based on airline regulations and how the luggage is transported.

1. Personal Item
   This includes small backpacks, handbags, or laptop cases that you can carry with you in the airplane cabin. They are usually stored under the seat in front of you.
2. Carry-On Luggage
   This is the classic cabin suitcase that you can bring on board with you. Generally, the size allowed by most airlines is 55 cm x 40 cm x 20 cm.
3. Checked Luggage
   This refers to the luggage that is checked in and stored in the airplane’s cargo hold. Large and heavy suitcases fall into this category.

What Size Suitcase Can I Bring on the Plane?

Most airlines allow a carry-on suitcase with dimensions of 55 cm x 40 cm x 20 cm. If your suitcase is larger, you’ll need to check it in and pay an additional fee.

Suitcases with Wheels: 2 or 4 Wheels?

2-Wheel Suitcases:

• Slide forward and backward.
• More durable for uneven sidewalks or bumpy streets.

4-Wheel Suitcases (Spinner):

• Glide in all directions.
• Ideal for airports and smooth surfaces.

I opted for a 4-wheel suitcase, and it was the right choice. In crowded airports like Miami or Los Angeles, being able to move effortlessly in any direction was a huge advantage.

How to Choose the Perfect Suitcase for Your Trip

• Traveling to multiple cities? Use a semi-rigid suitcase with 4 wheels to adapt to any situation.
• Carrying fragile items? Use a hard-shell suitcase to protect your belongings.
• Traveling for a few days? Use a small carry-on suitcase to avoid check-in fees.
• Traveling for an extended period? Use a large or extra-large suitcase to ensure you have enough space.
• Walking with your luggage? Choose a 2-wheel suitcase if the terrain is uneven, or a 4-wheel suitcase if you’ll be moving through airports and stations.

Choosing the right suitcase can mean the difference between a smooth trip or a travel nightmare. My personal experience taught me that semi-rigid suitcases with 4 wheels offer the best balance between mobility and protection. Analyze your type of trip and specific needs before purchasing a suitcase.

If you found this article helpful, share it with other travelers or tell us about your experience on our social media!

You may be interested in: Top 5 Mobile Apps for Frequent Travelers